|Source:||All England Reporter|
|Publisher Citation:|| All ER (D) 407 (Feb)|
Kevin Garnett QC sitting as a deputy judge of the High Court
|Representation||Josephine Hayes (instructed by Alexanders) for the claimant|
|Tina Kyriakides (instructed by Ralph Hume Garry) for the respondent|
|Judgment Dates:||20 February 2001|
Insolvency - Bankrupt's estate - Vesting in trustee - Retirement annuity policy effected by bankrupt prior to bankruptcy - Policies prohibiting surrender or assignment - Trustee in bankruptcy claiming to be entitled to payments - Whether trustee so entitled - Whether policy had vested in trustee on his appointment - Whether payments after-acquired property - Whether payments income of bankrupt - , , - European Convention on Human Rights, First Protocol, art 1.