|Source:||All England Reporter|
|Publisher Citation:|| All ER (D) 108 (May)|
|Neutral Citation:|| EWHC 1245 (Comm)|
|Court:||Queen's Bench Division, Commercial Court|
|Representation||Rachel Ansell and Gemma Morgan (instructed by DAC Beachcroft LLP) for the claimants.|
|Guy Blackwood and Gemma Morgan (instructed by Waltons & Morse LLP) for the defendant.|
|Judgment Dates:||11 May 2012|
Insurance - Liability insurance - Determination of proximate cause - Claimants and defendant being subscribing insurers to all risk policy commencing on goods' arrival at plant in England - Defendant being subscribing insurer to marine policy commencing on goods' departure from factory in Bucharest - Damage to goods being found - Parties disputing cause and timing of damage - Whether cause of damage being vibration during transit or wind excitation after arrival at plant - Whether inherent vice excluding defendant's liability.